I don't disagree with anything you've said here. But, I will add three thoughts: 1. FDR did a service to the American people with the TVA project. That put working men back on their feet in a way that restored their sense of pride and paid them well through their hard work. 2. Some people, like my maternal grandmother, had worked beyond hard her entire life. She was widowed three times due to the coal mines. She raised a house full of children on her own with no aid for many years. She had a milk cow, chickens, raised a garden and even raised a big every year, which she slaughtered on her own. She took in neighbor's laundry, which she washed on a wash board. It was just barely enough to keep everyone fed and clothed. In fact, there were times when the kids went to bed hungry. When FDR passed legislation that resulted in her getting a modest check every month, it was appropriate for the situation. There are situations that call for on going help, which should require the recipients doing their part.
The Democrats motivation in attracting life long voters on welfare was probably a factor. But, it did some good too. It just got taken far too far over the years. Now they are giving illegal immigrants benefits while American citizens struggle...and they are doing it with their tax payer dollars. Did you hear about the school district in Massachusetts that had to deny school bus service to 150students because they were out of funds? Meanwhile, a separate government agency stepped in a funded buses to transport students who are here illegally.
It is all a self serving sham by the government. But, aid to those who truly need it, should be given.
